Review on iPhone 3G
Two weeks after iPhone Party Hong Kong (which drained most of my energy) and using my first iPhone (16GB White, HK$498 unlimited data plan), I’ve finally got the time to write my little review here.
As a Mac fanatic, I bet you wouldn’t expect me to say a lot of bad things about it. To me, mobile phone is a very personal thing, much more personal than a “personal computer”, so this review is also a personal one. I judged the iPhone based on my own needs. What is a “pro” to me maybe a “con” to others.
Pros:
- Contrary to what most people think, I think it is reasonably priced. To me, HK$300 of the HK$498 is for the voice+unlimited data plan and the remaining HK$200 is for the iPhone cost, which works out to be HK$4,800 after 24 months - and I can’t find any decent smartphone of its level at that price (say, HTC Diamond is priced at HK$5,600).
- Surfing the web using Safari and getting constant access to all my email accounts via IMAP is a joy. I still miss the push email in Blackberry but it’d be hard to beat Gmail’s search and spam filtering. I’m glad that my company’s email switched to Gmail Apps (free) last month. iPhone + Gmail = Winner.
- Absolutely love the SMS conversation threads. I can’t recall how much time I wasted on browsing the “Sent” folder on my previous phones for previous messages. Would be perfect if I could backup those conversations by desktop sync. There’re some messages I’d love to keep. (Update: I found this free app called Syphone that backup SMS)
- iPhone’s touch-based keyboard is ideal for female or anyone with smaller fingers. I could type as fast as on a physical QWERT keyboard, and the auto-correction intelligence is quickly building up my own library of frequently-typed words. I do wish it can let me customize the keyboard and shortcuts in future, after all it’s virtual, why not?
Cons:
- Battery life. Given iPhone’s big, gorgeous screen and 3G speed, I don’t think anyone else than Apple has done a better job in optimizing the battery life. It’s not really a problem for casual users or people with a second charger at office. But if you’re constantly using it (who wouldn’t with a unlimited data plan?) for email/web and wandering in the streets without a charging spot like I do, you’d better make sure you get all your important phone calls before 4 p.m.
- Chinese input. The character recognition support looks cool at first, but it’s just too slow and unreliable for practical use. How hard it is to put common input methods like Cangjie (倉頡) and Jianyi (簡易) on it? Even better, put the 5-stroke input (T9 五筆輸入) we use on most Nokia/SE phones on it.
- To-do list. Where is my to-do list from iCal? Still can’t seem to find it on iPhone. This is a really basic feature.
- Copy-and-paste. A missing feature that has been pointed out by many before. Rumours said that Apple is working on it, I hope so!
These are just some of the things I like to highlight, as I believe there’re more than enough lengthy reviews for anyone to find online. Again, I don’t think iPhone is a phone for the mass. It’s a revolutionary phone for a niche market. If you are not the type of people who care about syncing your phone contacts to desktop, it’s probably not for you.
As with every type of design, one could only appreciates it after knowing the limits it has to be created within. iPhone 3G may have made some compromises, but I really think it’s the best in its class.












